On this page
- Quick answer
- When a hearing is held
- Reading the hearing notice
- Preparing in the days before the hearing
- Who can appear, and how the hearing runs
- Written submissions: the step that decides most cases
- A worked example: an evaporative cooler for vegetable storage
- What happens after the hearing
- Common mistakes
- Checklist before the hearing
- How MYCrave can help
- Close the objections, not the argument
- Frequently asked questions
You replied to the First Examination Report months ago. Then an email arrives with a date, a time, a video link and a list of objections the Controller says are still not met. For many applicants this is the moment the process starts to feel personal: a named officer, a fixed slot, and a decision to follow.
It helps to see the hearing for what it is. Section 14 of the Patents Act gives the applicant the right to be heard before the Controller disposes of an application on an adverse report, and section 80 says the same for any discretion exercised against an applicant. The hearing is that chance. It is short, it is focused on the open objections, and what you file in the fifteen days afterwards usually matters as much as what you say on the call.
Quick answer
A patent hearing is held when objections remain after your reply to the examination report. The procedure is in rule 28, applied to examination by rule 28A. You normally get ten days' notice (rule 28(4)), and the hearing may be held by video conference (rule 28(6)). An adjournment needs reasonable cause and a request with fee at least three days before the hearing; you get at most two adjournments of up to thirty days each (rule 129A). Evidence is given by affidavit (section 79). Written submissions and documents are due within fifteen days of the hearing (rule 28(7)). If the Controller still refuses, the order must give reasons under section 15, and you can appeal to the High Court within three months (section 117A).
When a hearing is held
Most hearings in prosecution follow the same path. You request examination, receive the FER, file a reply with amendments, and the Controller reviews it. If the Controller is satisfied, the patent is granted. If not, the Patent Office normally fixes a hearing and sends a notice listing what is still wrong.
You can also ask for one. Rule 28(2) lets the applicant request a hearing if it contests the objections, and the request has to be made earlier than ten days before the final date for putting the application in order under section 21. That is why a good FER reply ends with a hearing request: it costs nothing and preserves the right.
Hearings are also part of other proceedings: pre-grant representations under section 25(1), post-grant oppositions, and applications for amendment, restoration and revocation before the Controller. This guide deals with the examination hearing, which is by far the most common.
Reading the hearing notice
The notice is the most useful document you will get from the Patent Office, because it narrows the fight. Objections you answered well in the FER reply usually drop out. What remains is the Controller's current view.
Sort every remaining objection into one of four groups:
- Formal requirements. Form 1 details, Form 3, Form 5, Form 26, proof of right, priority documents. Fix these by filing before the hearing. There is no reason to argue about a missing form.
- Clarity and claim drafting. Section 10(4) and 10(5) objections about vague terms, unity or support. Most are cured by amended claims, which you should prepare in advance.
- Novelty and inventive step. Sections 2(1)(j) and 2(1)(ja) against cited documents. These need an argument, a claim chart and, often, a fallback claim set.
- Section 3 exclusions. 3(d), 3(e), 3(k), 3(i) and the rest. These are usually won or lost on how the claims are worded and what the specification proves.
Note what the Controller has written about your FER reply. A line such as "the applicant's arguments regarding D2 are not persuasive as D2 also discloses a pressure sensor" tells you exactly where to aim.
Preparing in the days before the hearing
Ten days is short. We work to a fixed sequence.
Day one: diarise and decide on time. Record the hearing date, the date three days before it (the last day to seek an adjournment), and the fifteen-day written submission date. If the inventor or counsel is unavailable, or you need test data that cannot be ready in time, request an adjournment now. Under the First Schedule it costs ₹1,000 per adjournment for a natural person, startup, small entity or educational institution, or ₹5,000 for others, on e-filing. You get two at most, so do not spend one casually.
Days two and three: rebuild the file. Read the specification, the FER, your reply and every cited document again. Check the publication date of each citation against the priority date of each claim. Make sure the amendments you made in the reply are within section 59: no new matter, and every amended claim within the scope of a claim as it stood before.
Days four to six: prepare the positions. For each open objection, write a short answer and the evidence behind it. For prior-art objections, prepare a claim chart showing which features of claim 1 each document discloses, partly discloses or lacks. Prepare at least one fallback claim set that you would accept if the Controller does not accept the main one.
Days seven and eight: evidence. Decide whether an affidavit will help. Under section 79, evidence before the Controller is given by affidavit unless the Controller directs otherwise. Useful affidavits include a technical expert explaining why a skilled person would not combine two documents, test results showing a technical effect, or comparative data for a section 3(d) objection. An affidavit should state the declarant's qualifications and confine itself to facts and expert opinion, not legal argument.
Day nine: the hearing note. Reduce everything to one or two pages: each objection, your answer in two or three sentences, the amendment you are offering, and the fallback. Send it to the Controller before the hearing if the notice or practice allows, and keep a copy open during the call.
Day ten: the run-through. Test the video link. Brief the inventor on the questions likely to come up. Agree who speaks on what.
Who can appear, and how the hearing runs
A registered patent agent can appear for the applicant, and so can an advocate. An applicant can also appear in person. An agent needs an authorisation on Form 26 on record (rule 135); if it is missing, file it before the hearing.
Most hearings now take place over video. Rule 28(6) treats a video hearing as having been held at the appropriate office, so there is no disadvantage to attending remotely. A typical hearing lasts a short time. The Controller goes through the remaining objections and asks how you propose to deal with each.
How to use that time well:
- Lead with the amendment if you have one. "We propose to amend claim 1 to add the feature of claim 4, which D1 does not disclose" is easier for the Controller to accept than five minutes on why the original claim was always fine.
- Answer the question asked. If the Controller's concern is that D2 shows a pressure sensor, explain why D2's sensor does something different in a different place, with the paragraph reference.
- Let the inventor explain the technology if the Controller asks a technical question. A short, plain explanation from the person who built it is often decisive.
- Do not introduce surprises. New documents or arguments that the Controller has not seen are better placed in the written submissions with a clear explanation.
- Note what is agreed. Controllers often indicate what kind of amendment would be acceptable. Write it down carefully, and reflect it exactly in the written submissions.
Written submissions: the step that decides most cases
Rule 28(7) requires written submissions and any relevant documents within fifteen days from the date of the hearing. Treat this as the real reply. The Controller's order is written from the file, and the written submissions are the most recent and complete statement of your case.
A strong written submission:
- Records briefly what happened at the hearing and what the Controller indicated.
- Takes each objection in the order of the hearing notice, with the response and the evidence.
- Attaches a clean set of amended claims and a marked copy showing each change against the claims on record, with the basis for each amendment in the specification.
- Attaches any affidavit, test report or document referred to.
- Ends with a clear request, such as grant on the amended claims.
Missing the fifteen days is a serious mistake. The Controller may decide on what is already on file, which by definition was not enough to avoid a hearing.
A worked example: an evaporative cooler for vegetable storage
The example is hypothetical. A Nashik startup has applied for a patent on a low-cost evaporative cooling chamber for onion storage. The FER raised novelty over D1, an evaporative cooler patent, and inventive step over D1 combined with D2, a paper on clay-pot cooling. The reply amended claim 1 and argued both points. The hearing notice says novelty is now accepted, but inventive step is not, because "D2 teaches porous walls and the skilled person would apply them to D1".
The preparation looks like this:
- The question. Would a skilled person, starting from D1, have added the porous wall arrangement of claim 1 with a reasonable expectation of success?
- The facts. D1 uses a fan and a wet pad. D2 is about passive cooling of drinking water in a sealed pot. Neither deals with stored produce, where humidity has to stay within a narrow band to stop the bulbs rotting.
- The evidence. An affidavit from the startup's agricultural engineer, with storage trials showing weight loss and rot rates for the claimed chamber, D1's design and a D1 design with porous walls added.
- The fallback. A claim set adding the humidity-venting slots described on page 9 of the specification, which neither document discloses.
At the hearing, the agent explains the difference in problem and offers the trial data. The Controller asks whether the venting slots are essential. The agent says they are the reason the trials worked and offers to add them to claim 1. The written submissions, filed on day twelve, contain the amended claims, the marked copy and the affidavit.
What happens after the hearing
The Controller then decides. If the objections are met, the application proceeds to grant. If not, the application is refused under section 15, and the order must give reasons. Indian courts have repeatedly sent back refusals that did not engage with the applicant's arguments, so an order that just repeats the objection is open to challenge.
Two routes are open against a refusal:
- Appeal to the High Court under section 117A, within three months of the order. Appeals are heard by the Intellectual Property Divisions of the High Courts with jurisdiction.
- Review by the Controller under section 77(1)(f), on Form 24 within one month of the decision (rule 130). Review is narrow and is not a second hearing on the merits.
Keep an eye on the section 21 deadline throughout. The application has to be put in order for grant within the time allowed from the FER, and an outstanding hearing does not make that problem disappear. Agree the timeline with your agent early.
Common mistakes
- Asking for an adjournment the day before the hearing, or for a third one.
- Arriving without amended claims and promising to "file something later".
- Offering amendments that add matter or widen a claim, which section 59 will not allow.
- Filing written submissions late, or filing ones that do not match what was said.
- Arguing about formal defects instead of simply fixing them before the date.
- Leaving the inventor out, then being unable to answer a technical question.
- Forgetting Form 26, so the agent's authority is in question on the day.
Checklist before the hearing
- Hearing date, adjournment cut-off and written submission date are diarised.
- Every open objection is sorted into formal, clarity, prior art or section 3.
- Formal defects have been fixed by filing before the hearing.
- Claim charts are ready for every cited document.
- A main and a fallback claim set are ready, each within section 59.
- Affidavits are signed and state the declarant's qualifications.
- The hearing note is one or two pages and tracks the notice.
- Form 26 is on record, and the video link has been tested.
- The inventor is briefed and available.
How MYCrave can help
MYCrave Consultancy & Services handles patent hearings within its patent registration practice, with 2,400+ FER and examination replies and a Registered Patent Agent (No. 5509) appearing before the Controller:
- Hearing notice review: the objections mapped, dates diarised and a decision on whether to seek an adjournment.
- Hearing preparation: claim charts, amended and fallback claim sets, and affidavits from inventors or independent experts.
- Appearance and written submissions: our professional fee for hearing representation starts at ₹4,500.
- Post-refusal advice on review or appeal under section 117A.
Close the objections, not the argument
Controllers want to grant patents that are properly limited and clearly written. A hearing goes well when you make that easy: an amendment that meets the objection, evidence that answers the technical doubt, and written submissions that turn what was said into a clean file. Prepare as if the written submissions were the hearing, because in the end they usually are.
Received a hearing notice on your patent application?
Share the notice, the FER, your reply and the specification. We will tell you which objections are live, what to amend and what evidence to prepare before the date. Call +91 76006 90996 or write to info@mycrave.co.in.
Plan your hearingFrequently asked questions
Is a patent hearing notice a refusal?
Do I have to attend the patent hearing in person?
Can I postpone a patent hearing?
When are written submissions due after a patent hearing?
Can I file new evidence at the hearing stage?
What can I do if my application is refused after the hearing?
Talk to a MYCrave IP expert. Free initial consultation, complete confidentiality.
Book a ConsultationAbout this guide
- The Patents Act, 1970, sections 14, 15, 21, 57, 59, 77, 79, 80, 117A, 127 and 132
- The Patents Rules, 2003, rules 28, 28A, 129A, 130 and 135, as amended by the Patents (Amendment) Rules, 2024
- First Schedule to the Patents Rules, 2003, as substituted in March 2024 (adjournment fee)
- Office of the CGPDTM, Manual of Patent Office Practice and Procedure
Procedure checked against the Patents Rules, 2003 as amended in March 2024. The Patents (Amendment) Rules, 2025 deal with adjudication of penalties and do not change the hearing timelines described here. Confirm the current position with the Office of the Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks.
Spotted an error? Tell us at info@mycrave.co.in and we will correct it. How we research, review and update this library is set out in our editorial policy. This guide is general information about Indian IP law and procedure, not advice on your specific matter.